Literary Fiction Brings New Depth to True Crime Genre
A literary exploration of a cold case in 'Gilgo Beach' by Maureen Anne Meehan delves into the human dynamics of crime investigation and justice themes
Gilgo Beach by Maureen Anne Meehan
Rex Huermann, a 60-year-old architect from Long Island, has been charged with multiple murders connected to the Gilgo Beach serial killings. The investigation began in 2010 when police discovered the remains of several individuals near Gilgo Beach, New York. Many of the victims were young women working as sex workers.
Available on Kindle & Paperback
We may earn a commission from this link.
Some stories demand to be told, even when they’re difficult to face. Maureen Anne Meehan’s latest novel ‘Gilgo Beach’ tackles one of America’s most haunting serial killer cases, but this isn’t your typical true crime thriller. It’s something far more nuanced – a thoughtful exploration of how we seek justice and honour victims whilst confronting the darkest aspects of human nature.
Meehan brings a unique perspective to this challenging subject. As a former judge turned acclaimed novelist, she understands both the legal complexities and the deeply human elements that make such cases so compelling. Her new book centres on the infamous Gilgo Beach serial killings that terrorised Long Island for over a decade, weaving fact and fiction into something both gripping and deeply respectful – part of true crime literature’s evolution towards more nuanced literary territory.
A Fresh Perspective on True Crime
The story follows Mary MacIntosh, a determined FBI investigator who partners with legendary profiler John Douglas to uncover the full scope of the crimes. What makes this particularly intriguing is how Meehan has timed her fictional narrative with real developments – Rex Heuermann’s arrest in July 2023 and subsequent charges for multiple murders brought renewed attention to a case many thought had gone cold.
Rather than sensationalising these tragic events, Meehan focuses on the human cost – the families seeking answers, the investigators pursuing truth and the communities forever changed by such violence. Like the best of classic crime fiction, the work balances suspense with profound human insight whilst requiring both courage and sensitivity.
From Courtroom to Literary Success
Meehan’s journey to writing wasn’t straightforward. Originally from Sheridan, Wyoming, she built a successful legal career before personal tragedy led her to channel her experiences into storytelling. The murder of her own legal secretary inspired her to begin writing legal thrillers – a deeply personal catalyst that brings authentic emotional weight to her work.
Her transition from the judiciary to literature has been remarkably successful. The New York Times Magazine has featured her work, establishing her as a significant voice in contemporary crime fiction. What sets her apart is how she brings real legal expertise to her narratives whilst never losing sight of the human stories at their heart.
A Different Kind of True Crime
‘Gilgo Beach’ arrives at a fascinating moment for the true crime genre. Audiences are increasingly sophisticated, seeking stories that go beyond simple procedural elements to explore deeper questions about justice, memory and healing. Meehan delivers exactly this kind of thoughtful approach, similar to how contemporary literary works addressing trauma illuminate the human stories at the heart of headline-making cases.
Her fictional Mary MacIntosh embarks on what the author describes as “a harrowing journey to bring long-buried secrets into the light.” But this isn’t about cheap thrills or exploiting tragedy for entertainment. Instead, Meehan examines the psychological toll on those who dedicate their lives to solving such cases and the quiet determination required to confront evil.
The book explores how MacIntosh balances this demanding work with her personal life, including sharing custody of four teenagers – a detail that adds real-world complexity to the character and reflects the challenges many women face in high-pressure careers.
Honouring the Victims
Perhaps most importantly, Meehan’s approach honours the victims whose lives were cut short. Too often, true crime can reduce real people to plot points or statistics. Here, the focus remains on the human cost and the importance of ensuring these women are remembered as more than just victims of a serial killer.
The timing of the novel’s release, coinciding with ongoing developments in the actual Gilgo Beach case, adds particular resonance. As new charges continue to be filed against Heuermann, Meehan’s fictional exploration offers a different lens through which to understand these tragic events.
The Power of Purposeful Storytelling
What emerges from ‘Gilgo Beach’ is a demonstration of how literature can serve a higher purpose than mere entertainment. Meehan proves that storytelling can be a means of processing trauma, challenging injustice and shining light on stories that might otherwise be forgotten. This approach places her work firmly within the tradition of narratives that explore complex family histories and generational impact.
Her background gives her work particular authority. Having spent years in courtrooms dealing with the legal system’s response to violence, she understands both its strengths and limitations. This knowledge infuses her fiction with authenticity that many crime writers lack.
The novel also reflects broader conversations about how we tell stories about violence, particularly violence against women. Meehan’s careful approach suggests a way forward that respects victims whilst still creating compelling narratives that can help us understand and process difficult realities.
A Literary Achievement
‘Gilgo Beach’ represents more than just another entry in the true crime genre. It’s a thoughtful meditation on justice, resilience and the importance of bearing witness to difficult truths. Through her fictional Mary MacIntosh, Meehan creates a character who embodies the determination required to seek justice whilst maintaining her humanity.
For readers seeking crime fiction with depth and purpose, this novel offers exactly that blend. Meehan has crafted something that is both a gripping thriller and a meaningful exploration of how we confront evil without losing ourselves in the process.
It’s storytelling with conscience – literature that entertains whilst serving a deeper purpose of honouring those whose voices were nearly lost forever.
About Maureen Anne Meehan
Maureen Anne Meehan is an accomplished author and former judge whose unique background brings authenticity to her legal thrillers. Originally from Sheridan, Wyoming, she holds both bachelor’s and master’s degrees in education before pursuing law and joining the judiciary.
Her writing career began after the tragic murder of her legal secretary, inspiring her to channel her legal expertise and personal experiences into compelling narratives. She is the author of the Mary MacIntosh mystery series and has received recognition from prestigious publications including The New York Times Magazine.
Beyond writing, Meehan is an accomplished athlete who has completed the Ironman World Championship Triathlon and numerous marathons, including the Boston Marathon. A mother of four, she currently practises law in Orange County, California, and lives in Southern California with her rescue cats.
Her novels, primarily set in Wyoming, explore themes of justice, resilience and the complex dynamics of small communities facing extraordinary circumstances. Her full bibliography is available on her website as well as on Amazon, and readers can follow her journey on Instagram @irishgirlsrock.
