---
title: How to Make the Right Call When There Is No Time
description: What the Hudson River landing and fire commanders teach about deciding under pressure, and a four-step method leaders can use when there is no time.
author: Dr Marina Nani (Editor-in-Chief)
date: 2026-11-22T19:00:00.602Z
updated: 2026-11-22T19:00:00.626Z
canonical: https://richwoman.co/article/decisions-under-pressure
image: https://cdn.nanimediahouse.com/pexels-7433904.webp
categories: Female leadership, The Corner Office
content_type: Guide
publication: Rich Woman Magazine
schema_type: Article
---

Most leadership advice assumes there is time to think: to gather the facts, consult the team and weigh the options. Crises take that time away. A supplier collapses, a system fails or a story breaks, and a decision that would normally take weeks has to be made in hours or minutes, with half the information missing and everyone looking at you.

That pressure is where many capable leaders stumble. Some freeze, waiting for a certainty that never arrives. Others grab the first familiar answer without checking whether it fits. Both reactions are human, and both can be overcome with practice. The clearest lessons come from people whose jobs force them to decide in seconds, such as pilots and fire commanders, and from one flight in particular.

About 100 seconds after take-off from LaGuardia Airport on 15th January 2009, US Airways Flight 1549 flew into a flock of Canada geese. Both engines lost almost all their thrust. Captain Chesley Sullenberger had roughly 208 seconds to choose between three options: turn back to LaGuardia, try for Teterboro Airport in New Jersey or put the aircraft down on the Hudson River. He judged that neither airport was within reach. The plane touched the water with its wings level, and all 155 people on board were rescued by boats.

It is one of the best-known decisions in aviation. What happened next is less well known, and it holds the more useful lesson for anyone who leads under pressure.

## The Answer That Only Exists in Hindsight

When investigators ran the flight again in simulators, some pilots managed to glide back to LaGuardia. On paper, it seemed, the river had not been the only option. But those simulator pilots turned towards the airport immediately after the bird strike, knowing exactly what had happened and what to do. The investigators concluded that the scenario did not account for real-world considerations, such as the seconds any crew needs to understand that both engines have failed. Allow for that, and the river was the right call.

Every leader falls into the same trap after a crisis. Once the outcome is known, the right decision looks obvious, and the person who made the call is judged against information they never had. The fair test, for yourself and for others, is narrower: was this a sound decision given what could be known in the time available? Leaders who learn to judge decisions that way make faster ones, as they stop waiting for a certainty that will only arrive afterwards.

## What Experience Really Does

There is a second lesson inside the cockpit. Sullenberger was not working through a list of options with scores attached. He recognised a situation, tested one course of action in his mind and moved on when it failed.

That is how experienced decision-makers work under pressure. When researchers interviewed fire commanders with an average of 23 years' experience, they expected to find them comparing options before acting. Instead, in more than 80% of decisions, the commanders recognised the situation as a familiar type and acted on the first workable plan, picturing how it would play out and adjusting if it would not work. They did not consider more than one option at a time.

The speed did not come from courage or brilliance in the moment. It came from a store of patterns built over years. That changes how a leader should prepare. The decisions that look instinctive in a crisis are the product of practice, review and honest reflection, done long before the pressure arrives.

## Why Pressure Pulls You Backwards

A ticking clock also changes how the brain works. Laboratory studies show that stress shifts thinking away from careful, goal-directed reasoning and towards habit. Under strain, people repeat what has worked before, even when the situation in front of them is new. Habit can save you when the situation really is familiar. It can sink you when it only looks familiar.

Procedures carry the same risk. The investigation into Flight 1549 found that the crew's checklist for losing both engines had been written with a high-altitude emergency in mind, where pilots have far longer to work through it. At low altitude, there was simply not enough time to finish it. Among its recommendations, the investigation called for checklists designed for dual-engine failures at low altitude. Good procedures are invaluable until the situation outruns the assumptions they were built on.

## A Method for the Next Hard Call

When time is short, these four steps keep a leader moving without freezing.

**Name what is happening.** Say it out loud, in one sentence, to yourself and your team. Naming the situation shifts you from shock into thought.

**Ask three questions.** What do I know for certain? What matters most to protect in the next few hours? What is the smallest action that protects it and keeps my options open?

**Choose, then set a check.** Make the decision and tell people when you will review it, whether that is in an hour or a day. A planned review lets you act before you are sure without pretending to be sure.

**Say why.** Explain the intention behind the decision as well as the decision itself. If people know what you are trying to protect, they can adapt sensibly when the situation shifts and you are not in the room.

Then build the store of patterns that made Sullenberger fast. After any difficult week, spend fifteen minutes with your team on three questions: what happened, what did we decide and what would we do differently? Over a year, those conversations become the experience you draw on when the next decision cannot wait.

Think back to that cockpit over New York and the 208 seconds between the geese and the river. The fear of choosing wrongly is real, and it is often what slows leaders down. Yet the greater risk is waiting for an answer that will only become clear afterwards. Choose one decision you are putting off now, ask the three questions and make the call with a date to review it. Certainty rarely arrives in time, so the best leaders learn to act well without it.
